Short answer: the four classic formulas give different numbers because each was fitted to different data, and none was designed to tell a healthy person what to weigh. For an average height they usually land within 2–4 kg of each other, all inside the healthy BMI range.

Who this guide is for: adults curious about "ideal weight" calculators. The results are estimates, not targets set by a health professional.

Where do the formulas come from?

Most started in hospital pharmacy, not weight loss. Devine (1974) published his equation to dose the antibiotic gentamicin; Robinson and Miller (both 1983) refitted it to life-insurance height–weight tables. Hamwi (1964) was a quick rule of thumb for diabetes diet planning. A 2000 review in Annals of Pharmacotherapy notes that none was validated as a measure of health.

How do the four formulas differ?

Each starts with a base weight at 5 feet (152.4 cm) and adds a fixed amount for every inch above it (kg):

FormulaMenWomen
Devine (1974)50 + 2.3 / in45.5 + 2.3 / in
Robinson (1983)52 + 1.9 / in49 + 1.7 / in
Miller (1983)56.2 + 1.41 / in53.1 + 1.36 / in
Hamwi (1964)48 + 2.7 / in45.5 + 2.2 / in

Hamwi adds the most per inch, so it gives the highest numbers for tall people. Miller adds the least, so it gives the highest numbers for short people and the lowest for tall ones.

How do they compare with a healthy BMI range?

The WHO healthy BMI range is 18.5–24.9. Multiplying those values by your height in metres squared gives a healthy weight range that is usually 15–17 kg wide. All four formulas fall inside it for average heights, so they are best read as one point inside a range, not a single correct weight.

Worked example

A woman 165 cm tall is about 4.96 inches over 5 feet. Her results:

FormulaIdeal weight
Devine56.9 kg
Robinson57.4 kg
Miller59.8 kg
Hamwi56.4 kg

The spread is 3.4 kg. Her healthy BMI range at 165 cm is about 50.4–67.8 kg, so every formula sits inside it.

When this guide may not fit your situation

Bottom line

Use the average of the formulas as a rough point of reference and the healthy BMI range as the real target zone. Waist size and how you feel matter at least as much as one number.

Frequently asked questions

Which ideal weight formula is most accurate?

None is accurate for an individual. Devine is the most widely used, mainly for medicine dosing.

Why do the formulas disagree?

Each was fitted to different data with a different base weight and amount per inch.

Are ideal weight formulas used by doctors?

Mostly to dose some medicines and set ventilator settings, not as weight-loss goals.

Is ideal weight the same as healthy weight?

No. Ideal weight is a single number; healthy weight is the whole BMI 18.5–24.9 range.

Do they work for short people?

They were designed for people taller than 5 feet. Below that, results are unreliable.

Do the formulas account for age?

No. Height and sex are the only inputs.

What about muscular people?

The formulas ignore muscle, so athletes may sit well above them and still be healthy.

Should I aim for my ideal weight?

Treat it as a rough reference. A healthy BMI range and a doctor’s advice are better guides.

Sources

  1. Pai MP, Paloucek FP. The origin of the "ideal" body weight equations. Annals of Pharmacotherapy, 2000;34(9):1066–1069.
  2. Devine BJ. Gentamicin therapy. Drug Intelligence & Clinical Pharmacy, 1974;8:650–655.
  3. Robinson JD, Lupkiewicz SM, Palenik L, et al. Determination of ideal body weight for drug dosage calculations. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, 1983;40(6):1016–1019.
  4. Miller DR, Carlson JD, Loyd BJ, Day BJ. Determining ideal body weight (and mass). American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, 1983;40(10):1622.
  5. World Health Organization. Obesity and overweight – fact sheet (BMI classification).

This guide is general information, not medical advice. Calculator results are estimates.